克拉霉素淡水生物水质基准与生态风险评估

    Water Quality Criteria for Freshwater Organisms and Ecological Risk Assessment of Clarithromycin

    • 摘要: 克拉霉素(CLA)属于大环内酯类抗生素, 具有广谱抑菌作用, 环境中CLA的残留会对水生生物产生潜在危害, 而我国尚缺乏CLA的淡水生物水质基准值。该研究搜集筛选了CLA对淡水生物的急慢性毒性数据, 共获得5门8科15条急性毒性数据和5门6科16条慢性毒性数据。采用物种敏感度分布法(SSD)、物种敏感度排序法(SSR)对CLA的水质基准进行推导, 经SSD方法推导出短期水质基准(SWQC)和长期水质基准(LWQC)分别为0.581和0.071 μg·L-1, 通过SSR方法推导出的基准最大浓度(CMC)和基准连续浓度(CCC)分别为3.741和0.919 μg·L-1, 最终采用SSD方法的结果作为保护我国淡水生物的水质基准。分别使用慢性毒作用带分析、熵值法和安全阈值法对我国部分水域进行生态风险评估。基于慢性毒作用带分析发现, CLA发生慢性中毒的危险性较大, 危险性等级为高度危险; 基于熵值法发现, CLA在我国部分水域中存在一定的生态风险; 基于安全阈值法发现, CLA在我国典型水体中几乎无风险。由于安全阈值法评估时数据量有限, 未能充分考虑水生生态环境的诸多因素对CLA分布的影响, 熵值法与慢性毒作用带分析结果相近, 且熵值法评估结果显示研究水体呈现一定的生态风险, 评估结果更能引起对CLA在淡水环境中生态风险的关注, 故以熵值法的生态风险评估结果作为最终结果。CLA在我国渭河关中段、北运河、珠江流域深圳河、珠江广州段、南明河、洪湖的风险评估等级为中等风险, 其余水域皆呈现低等风险。该研究可为CLA水质标准制定和流域水生态环境管理提供科学依据。

       

      Abstract: Clarithromycin (CLA) belongs to the macrolide class of antibiotics, which has a broad-spectrum antibacterial effect. The residue of CLA in the environment may pose potential hazards to aquatic organisms, while China lacks a freshwater biological water quality criteria for CLA. This study collected and screened acute and chronic toxicity data of CLA on freshwater organisms, obtaining 15 acute toxicity data from 5 phyla, 8 families, and 16 chronic toxicity data from 5 phyla, 6 families. Subsequently, the species sensitivity distribution method (SSD) and species sensitivity ranking method (SSR) were used to derive the water quality criteria of CLA. The short-term water quality criteria (SWQC) and long-term water quality criteria (LWQC) derived by SSD method were 0.581 and 0.071 μg·L-1, respectively. The criterion maximum concentration (CMC) and criterion continuous concentration (CCC) derived by the SSR method were 3.741 and 0.919 μg·L-1, respectively. Hence, the result of SSD method was adopted as the water quality criterion for protecting freshwater organisms in China. Subsequently, the ecological risk assessment of some water bodies in China was conducted using chronic toxicity zone analysis, entropy method, and safety threshold method. Based on the chronic toxicity zone analysis, it was found that the risk of CLA chronic poisoning was at highly danger level; Based on the entropy method, it was found that CLA poses certain ecological risks in some water bodies in China; Based on the safety threshold method, it was found that CLA posed almost no risk in typical water bodies in China. Due to the limited data volume in the safety threshold method assessment, the impact of many factors of the aquatic ecological environment on the distribution of CLA was not fully considered. The results of entropy method and chronic toxic zone analysis were similar, and the results of entropy method show that all the studied water bodies presented certain ecological risks. The estimation results can better draw attention to the ecological risks of CLA in freshwater environments. Therefore, the ecological risk assessment results of entropy method were taken as the final results The risk assessment level of Guanzhong section of Weihe River, the Beiyun River Basin, the Shenzhen River in the Pearl River Basin, the Guangzhou section of Pearl River, the Nanming River and the Honghu Lake were at moderate risk, while the rest of the water areas presented low risk. The research results of this paper can provide scientific basis for the formulation of CLA water quality criteria and the management of watershed water ecological environment.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回